Why does a bonus disappear from a listing? We compared six copies of our feed
Alexander B.
Published 4 min read
Between 18 October and 1 November 2026 we saved six copies of our feed. The newest copy holds 722 rows. Count a row as an operator, a market and a title, and the six copies hold 751 different rows between them. 718 of those are in every copy. The other 33 belong to three operators: Pin-Up, Melbet and Parimatch.
The 33 rows by operator
Nine of the 33 are Pin-Up's: three promotions, each of which arrived or left in all three markets at once. An enhanced-odds offer that ran every day was in the first four copies and gone from the last two. A free-bet insurance offer for the esports season turned up in the copy read on 26 October and was gone by 1 November. The third was a weekly quiz, which left and came back.
Melbet accounts for sixteen: eight slot-game items in each of its two markets, filed under free spins, present in the first five copies and gone from the sixth. Our rows do not say whether Melbet withdrew them or the page came out differently on that last read. When our free spins post was updated on 14 October, rows like these made up most of that category.
Parimatch's eight all moved in one step, between the copies of 28 October and 1 November. Four rows went out and four came in. Three of the incoming titles are outgoing ones with a ceiling added at the end, namely the daily and monthly rakeback and the weekly cashback, while the fourth names a different casino pack. Anyone comparing titles would count four offers ending and four starting, though on three of them the page may have changed only a few words.
A row that came back
Pin-Up's quiz has Wednesday in its name, and it showed up only in Wednesday copies. Its three rows were in the copy whose newest read fell on Wednesday 21 October, missing from the Friday and Monday copies, back on Wednesday 28 October, and gone again by Sunday 1 November.
On both appearances the rows carried the same row numbers and the same creation date, 24 July. That fits how the collector treats a missing row. When a read of a page finds offers but not a given one, that row is marked as gone, and if a later read finds the offer again, the mark is cleared and the row keeps its number and its history.
An offer tied to one day of the week is caught only when the day and the read coincide. Our copies were two to four days apart, and this one turned up in two of the six.
What makes a row the same row
Every row has a key, and the key decides whether a changed offer updates its row or retires it and starts a new one. If the offer carries a promo code, the code is the key. None of ours does. Otherwise, when every offer on a page links to a page of its own, the last piece of that link is the key. When they do not, the title is, lower-cased and with stray punctuation trimmed off the ends.
All seven Parimatch rows share one address, so for them the title is the key, and adding a ceiling to a title made a new row and retired an old one. Pin-Up cards each link to their own page, so under the same rule a reworded Pin-Up title would stay on its existing row.
Twelve of the 718 rows present in every copy changed a stored field between copies and kept their row. On six esports rows the address changed while the title stayed. The other six were welcome rows whose stored amount was rewritten at every step from one copy to the next. That amount is in a currency none of our markets uses, which is why it is one of the fields the site leaves empty and why none is quoted here.
Rows still dated 3 October
Four Marathonbet rows are in every copy, unaltered, and every one carries a read date of 3 October. In the feed pulled on 3 November they are the only rows with a date that old. Our collector's warning for that page on 1 November said it captured the page, parsed no offers, and left four live rows unrefreshed. The code is built that way on purpose: a read that finds nothing removes nothing, since the page may have been blocked or the parser may have failed.
Parimatch's rows were stuck at the same date for most of October: all seven still carried a 3 October read date in the copy of 28 October, and their replacements arrived only in the copy read on 1 November.
When a page says the offer ends today
When a countdown or a banner saying an offer ends today is what is moving you toward a deposit, leave the operator's site and come back to the decision tomorrow, if at all. If walking away has stopped working for you, ask the operator to close your account or exclude you, and use your own device's tools to block gambling sites. What is available in each market is set out on our responsible gambling page.
Settle the most you will put in while you are still reading a listing. Make it a sum you would not miss if all of it went. Every game and every bet is priced with a margin for the operator, so over time play tends to cost money and cannot replace an income. Every offer is subject to the operator's T&Cs, and those can be rewritten at any time. Nobody under 21 in Kazakhstan, or under 18 in Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan, may gamble.
Tags
- catalogue
- freshness
- rotation
- how-to
Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you follow one to an operator and later register or deposit, we may earn a commission from that operator. It costs you nothing, and it does not change the offer you are given or the order offers appear in.
Ready to see today's listed offers?
Open the Telegram bot to browse bonuses filtered to your country — no sign-up, no email.
Open the Telegram BotFrequently Asked Questions
Why did a bonus I saw on a listing site disappear?+
Of the 751 rows in the copies of our feed saved between 18 October and 1 November 2026, 29 were missing from the newest copy, which can mean an offer ended or only that its title changed.
Can a bonus come back after it has gone?+
One Pin-Up offer, a weekly quiz, was missing from the two copies of our feed after 21 October 2026 and back on its old rows in the next.
How often does a listing site update its bonuses?+
Our collector reads each operator's page in turn, and on 1 November 2026 every row in our feed but four came from a read made that day. The four, all from one operator, were still dated 3 October.
Does a changed title mean the offer changed?+
Sometimes only the wording did. In our copy of 1 November 2026, three new Parimatch rows were older titles with a ceiling added, and because Parimatch rows are matched by title, each counted as a new offer.